Editorial Policies

Focus and Scope

The journal of space syntax is a peer-reviewed, open access academic journal focused on research investigating relations between society and space. While grounded in the research field known as space syntax, from which the journal draws its name, the journal considers its field of inquiry in a broad sense and invites articles of a wide range of theories, approaches and methods addressing its broader scope. The journal accepts both quantitative and qualitative research, empirical, theoretical, methodological and other kinds of articles, where the inclusion is based on the quality of the contribution and its relevance for the journal's scope.

Thematically, the journal accepts regular research articles as well as articles on education, practice, software, method development, and many other kinds of articles. The journal encourages a variety of themes and topics ranging from architecture to geography, the smaller scale of local places or small buildings up to the larger scales of cities, regions and beyond. Articles on relations between space and use, interpretation, meaning, practice, culture, and any other conception of how space and society interrelates are welcome, where choice of section should be based on rigour of research, depth of investigation, thoroughness of contextualisation, and type of contribution. All topics and themes are therefore possible to all sections, providing they meet the high quality standards expected by the journal for each section.

 

Section Policies

Full Article

Full articles will normally describe previously unpublished, original and potentially significant research, or present important new data or case studies, or shed fresh light upon an established subject. The article can concern theory, methodology, empirical research, conceptual development, or many other questions, characterized by providing a rigorous article with substantial contributions to the journal’s field of investigation. Empirically, topics may range from an in-depth study of a single space, place or building to the analysis of entire towns, cities, landscapes or regions and the narrative may shed light on the past, inform the present or shape the future. The author/s need not use space syntax theories or methods directly in their research, rather, the criteria is whether the subject matter is of interest to the journal readership. The account should be reasoned, coherent, logical and well organised, and should conform to the academic principles of rigour, precision, economy and replicability. The journal accepts contributions using both qualitative and quantitative methods, and a wide range of different analytical and interpretative research. The paper should be written in the active voice, the third person and the past tense, except when presenting generally accepted facts. Gender-neutral language should be adopted. Contributions should be clearly describing the background to and purpose of the research, the main research question or hypothesis, provide account of the actual research that was conducted, and key findings or results should be spelled out, together with any important conclusions or further questions that arose out of the research. Papers submitted to this section of the journal should normally be between 6000 and 8000 words long. See also Instructions for Authors.

Checked Open Submissions Checked Indexed Checked Peer Reviewed

Short Article

Short articles will normally describe previously unpublished, original and potentially significant work. Short articles can cover the same range of issues and types of articles as full articles, but can be more experimental or explorative, or characterised as reporting and reflecting articles on conducted work.
Short articles can for instance be on approaches to research methodology or innovative software developments, descriptive articles on design work either as unbuilt competition entries, design proposals, or recently completed, fully realized and built projects. They can also be on pedagogical approaches and educational research. What characterizes short articles is that they take a more descriptive, reporting character and can focus the contextualization of the knowledge presented to more narrowly and specifically concern that which is addressed. They can furthermore be characterized by presenting methods and software, pedagogical approaches, or design work that is yet to be fully tested empirically or otherwise. Papers should still be rigorously written and presented, clearly describing the research question and the case—whether it is a piece of software, a methodology, a design work, a pedagogical approach, or any other issue—clearly present the knowledge context and similarities and difference to other work, the theoretical basis of the work, findings and conclusions. A short article in the Journal of Space Syntax will be rigourously peer-review and academic standards will be upheld just as for full articles, while having a higher acceptance for preliminary, development and experimental work or design-focused contributions. Papers submitted to this section of the journal should normally be between 3000 and 5000 words long. See also Instructions for Authors.

Checked Open Submissions Checked Indexed Checked Peer Reviewed

Forum

The Forum is an arena that gathers together written pieces with personal opinions, points of view and considered reflections on the state of the field, responses to previously-published papers and rejoinders that rebut or deny the assertions made in a previously-published response, and any other matters that are likely to be of interest to the space syntax community. Contributions to Forum should not usually exceed 1500 words. Forum articles are subject to editorial review and if deemed appropriate an additional double-blind review. See also Instructions for Authors.

Checked Open Submissions Unchecked Indexed Checked Peer Reviewed

News

News articles are brief reports of news of interest for the journal readership. News are expected to hold academic significance and report on, for instance, events, new software, workshop results or similar that researchers seek to disseminate with the readership while not writing a paper. News articles should not exceed 800 words. News articles are subject to editorial review for relevance and quality, and will be published continuously as added articles to the latest issue up until ca. one month before the release of the next issue.

Checked Open Submissions Unchecked Indexed Unchecked Peer Reviewed

Book Reviews

Book reviews should present and critically discuss books of relevance for the journal readership. Generally, a book review therefore always presents strong and weak points of a work, and contextualises the work in the overall field of inquiry of the journal. A book review submission is subject to editorial review, and it is advised to contact the editorial team in advance if planning to submit a review.

Checked Open Submissions Unchecked Indexed Unchecked Peer Reviewed

JOSS Extended

JOSS Extended submissions are subject to similar rigorous peer-review as all other submission forms, but recognising the wide scope of the journal it is clear that there are valuable contributions that would not be suitable within the standard submission formats. Rather than creating a wide range of different submission formats, ‘JOSS Extended’ allows other types of articles to be submitted, where the length is not pre-defined. A submission to JOSS Extended will be evaluated so that character, length, and type of argument must follow from one another to provide a solid and qualitative whole, and is not a place to submit an article that just happened to be too long; editorial screening and decisions will be made on suitability on a case-by-case basis. JOSS Extended will be published in regular issues, but due to the format and process it may take longer between submission and publication. The primary submission format to JOSS remains the standard article formats, and JOSS Extended will be open only for submissions that for discernible reasons require deviation from these formats.

Checked Open Submissions Checked Indexed Checked Peer Reviewed
 

Peer Review Process

The journal of space syntax practices a double-blind review process for all articles, and editorial review for forum, news, and book review contributions. The double-blind reviews are conducted by experts in the field, and the journal consistently recruits reviewers to ensure that all contributions get a fair and high-quality peer-review for its theme, topic, type, and method. The Journal of Space Syntax strives to review papers that pass through double-blind review within two months of submission, but the review times may vary depending on how close to the next issue a submission is made.

JOSS Review Process
Image and video hosting by TinyPic

1. The Journal of Space Syntax follows a standard procedure where a suggestion of a minor revision is reviewed by the editorial team and a major revision is sent on a renewed double-blind peer review. However, reviewers are given the option to suggest deviations from this: a reviewer can suggest major revisions, but consider the requested revisions to be of a kind the editorial team can review. A reviewer can also suggest minor revisions but request to receive the paper to review amendments. Generally, the Journal of Space Syntax requests revisions based on all reviewer comments. All papers pass through a final editorial review which is aimed at smaller editorial revisions or completions.

2. Copy-editing is always sent to the author to confirm or reject the copy-editor’s suggestions. In this process it is also possible that the editorial team will request additional material such as improved figures or clarified diagrams, etc.

3. Full lines represent the general case; for instance, the journal generally follows reviewers’ suggestions unless there are specific circumstances, or the editor considers the requested amendments to be either smaller or larger than the reviewers. If the author decides to submit a paper after a notification of rejection, the paper will be considered as a new submission; the initial screening will also make sure that such a resubmission holds revisions enough to be considered a new submission. Resubmitting a rejected paper with only some revisions will lead to immediate editorial rejection.

 

Open Access Policy

This journal provides immediate open access to its content on the principle that making research freely available to the public supports a greater global exchange of knowledge.

 


ISSN: 2044-7507